Greetings from Brussels!
For my money, the big news in Europe this week comes out of Düsseldorf, Germany. The news involves a
Fast forward to this week, and the case was back on the slate at the Düsseldorf court in the front of Kühnen to deliver a final verdict on Facebook’s appeal. The court’s findings were inconclusive: “The question of whether Facebook is abusing its dominant position as a provider on the German market for social networks because it collects and uses the data of its users in violation of the GDPR cannot be decided without referring to the [Court of Justice of the European Union].” The court effectively deferred the verdict concluding that guidance from the CJEU is required in that the original restriction order concerns arguments and allegations relating to a violation of EU data protection law. Moreover, at the heart of the issue is whether Germany’s competition authority may have exceeded its authority in the application of competition law on what is fundamentally a question of data protection and privacy.
The cartel’s case remains fairly unique in Europe, with the approach of fusing tenets of both competition and privacy law into its proceedings and subsequent decision. The basic question though has merit: When does a company’s use and default harvesting of digital data to its own ends outweigh market, and by extension, consumer benefits? Indeed, the overlap of competition with data protection law and policy is not new area of discussion and, in addition to dominant market positions, has been debated in relation to mergers and acquisitions, for example. As a side note, the Competition Commission of India ordered an investigation into WhatsApp’s new privacy policy for allegedly breaching the nation's competition law on the grounds that forced consent to sharing user data with other Facebook companies was made a precondition for availing of their services. The new privacy policy goes into effect in India in May and comes at a time when WhatsApp is expanding its digital payment services to Indian customers — India is WhatsApp’s biggest market with more than 500 million users.
Back in Europe, the German competition case could have explosive repercussions depending on where the CJEU lands. This will take time to resolve but is well worth keeping an eye on. For its part, Facebook is standing their ground, saying the Düsseldorf court expressed doubts as to the legality of the Bundeskartellamt decision. The company also argued the order violates European law. The court will make a formal submission to the CJEU in the coming weeks.