A federal judge has ruled that the U.S. National Security Agency’s (NSA) phone metadata collection program is likely unconstitutional, Politico reports. U.S. District Court Judge Richard Leon, an appointee of former President George W. Bush, said the program appears to violate the Fourth Amendment, and the Justice Department has not successfully demonstrated that the program has thwarted terrorism.

In the 68-page opinion, Leon wrote, “I cannot imagine a more ‘indiscriminate’ and ‘arbitrary invasion’ than this systematic and high-tech collection and retention of personal data on virtually every single citizen for purposes of querying it and analyzing it without judicial approval.” Leon later added, “Surely, such a program infringes on ‘that degree of privacy’ that the founders enshrined in the Fourth Amendment.”

The temporary injunction, which would prevent the NSA from continuing the collection program, has been stayed pending appeal.

In defending the surveillance program, the U.S. government has relied on a 1979 Supreme Court decision, Smith v. Maryland, in which the top court upheld the warrantless capture by law enforcement of phone numbers dialed by a suspect because he did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy when dialing the numbers. Leon argued, in his decision, that the Supreme Court in 1979 would not “have ever imagined how the citizens of 2013 would interact with their phones.”

Leon continued, “The ubiquity of phone use has dramatically altered the quantity of information that is now available and, more importantly, what that information can tell the government about people’s lives … I cannot possibly navigate these uncharted Fourth Amendment waters using as my North Star a case that predates the rise of cell phones.”

The ruling brought privacy to the headlines across the media spectrum Monday night and into Tuesday. On Sunday night, the NSA gave TV news magazine 60 Minutes an inside look at the agency, prompting criticism from some sources that the report was one-sided and didn’t interview Snowden or journalist Glenn Greenwald.

After the ruling on Monday, Snowden said, “I acted on my belief that the NSA’s mass surveillance programs would not withstand a constitutional challenge, and that the American public deserved a chance to see these issues determined by open courts.” Also on CNN’s AC360, Greenwald said the ruling vindicated the actions of Snowden. CNN contributor Jeffrey Toobin, who will be a keynote at the IAPP Global Privacy Summit in March, disagreed. “I don’t think this vindicates him, but it certainly comes a lot closer to vindicating him than anything else has.”

Reaction to the ruling has been widespread. The Editorial Board of The New York Times wrote the ruling is a “powerful rebuke of mass surveillance.” The board opined that the ruling “is an enormous symbolic victory for opponents of the bulk-collection program and a reminder of the importance of the adversarial process.”

American Civil Liberties Union Deputy Legal Director Jameel Jaffer wrote, “We hope that Judge Leon’s thoughtful ruling will inform the larger conversation about the proper scope of government surveillance powers, especially the debate in Congress about the reforms necessary to bring the NSA’s surveillance activities back in line with the Constitution.”

In the Electronic Frontier Foundation’s (EFF) Deep Links blog, the EFF’s Trevor Timm called the ruling “historic” and “an important first step in ensuring Americans’ privacy is protected in the digital age.”

George Washington University Law School Prof. Daniel Solove wrote about the ruling and the Fourth Amendment."I find much merit to the ... court's analysis," he wrote. "I have long argued that Smith was wrongly decided..."

Eugene Robinson, a columnist for The Washington Post, wrote, “If we want our privacy back, we’re going to have to fight for it.”

Finally, Stanford Center for Internet and Society Director of Civil Liberties Jennifer Granick called the ruling “tremendously important” but warns the agency, as well as the executive branch, will find “creative ways” to sidestep legislation, including the proposed USA FREEDOM Act.


Written By

Jedidiah Bracy, CIPP/E, CIPP/US


If you want to comment on this post, you need to login.


Board of Directors

See the esteemed group of leaders shaping the future of the IAPP.

Contact Us

Need someone to talk to? We’re here for you.

IAPP Staff

Looking for someone specific? Visit the staff directory.

Learn more about the IAPP»

Daily Dashboard

The day’s top stories from around the world

Privacy Perspectives

Where the real conversations in privacy happen

The Privacy Advisor

Original reporting and feature articles on the latest privacy developments

Privacy Tracker

Alerts and legal analysis of legislative trends

Privacy Tech

Exploring the technology of privacy

Canada Dashboard Digest

A roundup of the top Canadian privacy news

Europe Data Protection Digest

A roundup of the top European data protection news

Asia-Pacific Dashboard Digest

A roundup of the top privacy news from the Asia-Pacific region

IAPP Westin Research Center

Original works. Groundbreaking research. Emerging scholars.

Advertise in IAPP Publications

Find out how to get your message in front the people you want to reach. Download a media kit now.

Get more News »

Find a KnowledgeNet Chapter Near You

Network and talk privacy at IAPP KnowledgeNet meetings, taking place worldwide.

Women Leading Privacy

Events, volunteer opportunities and more designed to help you give and get career support and expand your network.

IAPP Job Board

Looking for a new challenge, or need to hire your next privacy pro? The IAPP Job Board is the answer.

Join the Privacy List

Have ideas? Need advice? Subscribe to the Privacy List. It’s crowdsourcing, with an exceptional crowd.

Find more ways to Connect »

Find a Privacy Training Class

Two-day privacy training classes are held around the world. See the complete schedule now.

Online Privacy Training

Build your knowledge. The privacy know-how you need is just a click away.

The Training Post—Can’t-Miss Training Updates

Subscribe now to get the latest alerts on training opportunities around the world.

New Web Conferences Added!

See our list of upcoming web conferences. Just log on, listen in and learn!

Train Your Staff

Get your team up to speed on privacy by bringing IAPP training to your organization.

Learn more »

CIPP Certification

The global standard for the go-to person for privacy laws, regulations and frameworks

CIPM Certification

The first and only privacy certification for professionals who manage day-to-day operations

CIPT Certification

The industry benchmark for IT professionals worldwide to validate their knowledge of privacy requirements

Certify Your Staff

Find out how you can bring the world’s only globally recognized privacy certification to a group in your organization.

Learn more about IAPP certification »

Get Close-up

Looking for tools and info on a hot topic? Our close-up pages organize it for you in one easy-to-find place.

Where's Your DPA?

Our interactive DPA locator helps you find data protection authorities and summary of law by country.

IAPP Westin Research Center

See the latest original research from the IAPP Westin fellows.

Looking for Certification Study Resources?

Find out what you need to prepare for your exams

More Resources »

GDPR Comprehensive: Registration Open

New! Intensive two-day GDPR training led by the sharpest minds in the field. It's a can't-miss event.

The Congress Is Cancelled

The IAPP Europe Data Protection Congress 2015 is cancelled. Click through to learn more.

Sponsor an Event

Increase visibility for your organization—check out sponsorship opportunities today.

Exhibit at an Event

Put your brand in front of the largest gatherings of privacy pros in the world. Learn more.

More Conferences »

Become a Member

Start taking advantage of the many IAPP member benefits today

Corporate Members

See our list of high-profile corporate members—and find out why you should become one, too

Renew Your Membership

Don’t miss out for a minute—continue accessing your benefits

Join the IAPP»